Chapter 9 - The Interview
Ben’s formal forensic interview took place five days after surgery.
James was not allowed in the room.
Neither was Rachel.
That frustrated him until Elena explained why.
“His account needs to be his.”
James understood intellectually.
Emotionally, he wanted to stand beside his son through every sentence.
Instead he waited in a small room with a vending machine and a box of tissues he refused to touch.
The interview specialist, Dana Kim, spoke with Ben alone while investigators observed through a separate system.
She did not ask leading questions.
She did not tell him Victoria was bad.
She did not ask him to agree with theories.
She let him describe.
Some things James later learned from Ross.
Others he never asked to know.
Ben described the basement room.
The first time Victoria locked him there was after he called Rachel from a school office.
Victoria told James Ben had been disciplined for stealing a teacher’s phone.
The second time was after he told a neighbor he wished Claire were alive.
The third time lasted overnight.
Ben knew because he heard the furnace cycle and eventually morning traffic.
There were more.
He stopped counting after thirty-seven marks.
The marks police photographed were not days.
They were separate confinements.
James left the waiting room and vomited in a bathroom.
When he returned, Rachel handed him water.
Neither spoke.
Ben also explained the fake messages.
Victoria had shown him screenshots that appeared to come from James.
He is exhausting me.
Maybe boarding school would be best.
I need space from him.
James later saw copies recovered from Victoria’s laptop.
They were crude if inspected carefully.
But a nine-year-old had no reason to inspect them.
He trusted the photograph beside his father’s name.
Then came the arm.
Ben had found the hidden staircase because Victoria forgot to latch the bookcase.
He heard her arguing with Eric Voss about records.
Eric said, “If anyone audits those contracts, I’m not taking the fall.”
Ben did not know what it meant.
He understood only that they were talking about Claire.
He opened the locked box.
Victoria caught him.
She pulled the box.
Ben refused to release it.
He fell down four steps.
The fracture happened then.
What followed was worse because it involved choices.
Victoria could have called an ambulance.
She did not.
Eric arrived.
He said the arm required emergency care.
Victoria refused.
According to Ben, Eric threatened to leave.
Victoria threatened to report him for stealing controlled medication.
Eric stayed.
The cord came from a black nylon tie Victoria used to secure rolled yoga mats.
She wrapped it above the injury.
Eric told her it was too tight.
She loosened it.
After he left, Ben begged for James.
Victoria tightened it again.
James cried when Ross told him.
He did not hide it.
“He asked for me.”
Ross nodded.
“And she knew I would come.”
“Yes.”
“So she made sure he couldn’t call.”
“Yes.”
The interview also answered the question of the cardboard note.
Three days before hospitalization, Ben’s fingers became numb.
Victoria left him alone in the kitchen for several minutes.
He tore cardboard from a cereal box.
He wrote HELP ME.
He tried to slide it through the top of the cast so someone might find it later.
The blue key went in the same way.
“Why the key?” James asked.
Ross looked at her notes.
“He said if something happened to him, he wanted someone to find the room.”
James looked away.
A nine-year-old had made an evidence plan because the adults in his life had failed him.
The final piece concerned the hospital.
On the morning Ben was admitted, he collapsed near the upstairs bathroom.
A housekeeper named Teresa Alvarez found him.
Victoria ordered Teresa to leave.
Teresa refused.
She threatened to call 911.
Victoria drove Ben herself rather than allow an ambulance into the house.
Teresa had already contacted police by the time they arrived at St. Catherine’s.
That was why Victoria had been frantic.
Not because she suddenly understood Ben was sick.
Because the housekeeper had stopped obeying.
“Where is Teresa?” James asked.
“Safe,” Ross said.
“Can I speak to her?”
“Not yet.”
James nodded.
He was learning that wanting access did not mean deserving it.
Ben emerged from the interview tired but calm.
James stood.
Ben walked to him slowly, his arm supported in a sling.
“Can we go home?”
James’s heart stopped.
The Carter house was still a crime scene.
And even when police released it, James could not imagine bringing Ben back to the basement, the office, the hallway where so much had happened.
“No.”
Ben’s eyes widened.
James quickly continued.
“We don’t have to go back there.”
“Ever?”
James had not decided.
Then he realized Ben had.
“Ever, if you don’t want to.”
Ben looked at him.
“Where will we live?”
“I don’t know yet.”
That answer frightened James more than it frightened Ben.
Ben nodded.
“Okay.”
Rachel smiled faintly.
James looked at her.
She understood something he was only beginning to learn.
For a child who had lived inside someone else’s rigid rules, uncertainty could be frightening.
But it could also mean choice.
As they walked toward the elevator, Ross received a phone call.
She stopped.
“James.”
He turned.
“What?”
“Forensics unlocked one of Victoria’s prepaid phones.”
“And?”
Ross’s face tightened.
“There are messages with Eric.”
James waited.
“They begin four years ago.”
Before James married Victoria.
Before she moved into his house.
May you like
Before Rachel disappeared from Ben’s life.
And six months before Claire died.
