Chapter 3 - Who They Believed Before
Brianna was suspended for five school days while the investigation continued.
Zoe received three.
The decision made nobody happy.
Some parents said it was too harsh.
Others called it absurdly lenient.
Lily hated that everyone had an opinion about a bathroom they had never entered.
By Monday morning, someone had leaked the basic story.
Not the video.
Not yet.
But enough.
Trash.
Sink.
Brianna.
Lily.
The Hawthorne Fellowship.
Students stared as Lily walked through the main hallway.
She kept her soaked bag at home and carried an old red backpack Claire found in the closet.
It belonged to her father.
One zipper stuck.
One strap was frayed.
Lily preferred it to buying something new.
Sophie Chen met her near the library.
“You okay?”
“No.”
“Good.”
Lily frowned.
Sophie shrugged.
“I’m tired of everyone asking like you’re supposed to say yes.”
That made Lily smile.
Sophie lowered her voice.
“People think the bathroom thing was about Hawthorne.”
“It might have been.”
“Brianna’s friends are saying you accused her of plagiarism because you’re losing.”
“I never accused her officially.”
“Doesn’t matter.”
Lily stopped walking.
“Do you have the screenshots from her presentation?”
Sophie nodded.
“Why?”
“Send them to Principal Hayes.”
“I already did.”
Lily stared.
Sophie smiled.
“You need more efficient friends.”
In English class, Lily sat behind Zoe’s empty chair.
She felt guilty about being relieved Zoe was suspended.
Zoe had never been as cruel as Brianna.
But she had laughed.
Blocked the door.
Repeated insults.
Lily had spent months excusing her because Zoe sometimes looked uncomfortable.
Discomfort was not resistance.
At lunch, Principal Hayes called Lily into her office.
Dean Bell was there.
So was school counselor Angela Reed.
Hayes placed an old email on the desk.
“Do you recognize this?”
Lily read it.
It was from January.
Her message to faculty advisor Melanie Cross.
I don’t know if this counts as bullying, but Brianna keeps hiding my things and telling people I only got into Ashford because they needed scholarship students for diversity brochures.
Lily’s stomach tightened.
“Yes.”
Ms. Cross had responded:
I’m sorry you’re feeling uncomfortable. Brianna can have a strong personality. I encourage you to avoid unnecessary conflict and focus on your own goals.
Lily looked at Hayes.
“You found it.”
“Yes.”
“You said you didn’t know about complaints.”
“I didn’t.”
“Should you have?”
Hayes did not defend herself.
“Yes.”
Lily appreciated that.
Not enough to stop being angry.
“What happens to Ms. Cross?”
“Her handling of your message is being reviewed.”
“Is she in trouble?”
“That is not yet determined.”
Lily looked away.
She had not wanted to ruin anyone’s career.
That thought made her angry too.
Why did reporting mistreatment feel like doing something to the person who ignored it?
Counselor Reed spoke gently.
“Lily, you are not responsible for consequences that come from adults’ decisions.”
Lily nodded.
She did not entirely believe it yet.
Hayes showed her two other reports.
Names redacted.
One student had complained Brianna spread edited screenshots after a disagreement.
Another reported belongings being hidden during gym.
Neither had resulted in discipline.
“Why not?” Lily asked.
“In one case, the student withdrew the complaint.”
“Why?”
“We don’t know.”
“And the other?”
“No witnesses.”
Lily laughed bitterly.
“So Brianna was right.”
Hayes frowned.
“About what?”
“Who do you think they’ll believe?”
Silence.
Lily continued.
“She knew how this worked.”
That mattered.
Brianna had not invented confidence in the restroom.
She had learned it.
Several times, someone had spoken.
Several times, nothing serious happened.
Evidence had been missing.
Adults had preferred ambiguity.
Brianna had interpreted ambiguity as permission.
Hayes folded the reports.
“We’re changing that.”
Lily looked at her.
“Because there’s video now?”
“Because we should have changed it earlier.”
After the meeting, Lily stopped by the custodial office.
Ms. Thompson was labeling supply bottles.
“You’re supposed to knock.”
Lily knocked on the open door.
“Better?”
“Much.”
Lily stood awkwardly.
“I wanted to say thank you.”
Ms. Thompson continued writing.
“You already did.”
“No. For recording.”
That made her stop.
“I almost didn’t.”
Lily blinked.
“Why?”
“Because employees are told not to record students.”
“Then why did you?”
Ms. Thompson capped the marker.
“Because I heard Brianna ask who people would believe.”
She looked at Lily.
“I have worked in schools for twenty-three years.”
“And?”
“I know what it sounds like when somebody thinks another person has no witness.”
Lily swallowed.
“Have you seen her do stuff before?”
“I’ve seen aftermath.”
“What does that mean?”
“Wet uniforms. Crying. Things in toilets.”
Lily stared.
“You knew?”
“I suspected.”
“Did you report it?”
“Yes.”
“What happened?”
“Sometimes kids said nothing happened when administrators asked.”
Lily understood immediately.
Fear.
Ms. Thompson continued.
“One girl told me she couldn’t afford for Brianna’s mother to dislike her family.”
“What?”
“She wouldn’t explain.”
Lily sat slowly.
Meredith Cole’s influence extended beyond donations.
She sat on the Parent Foundation.
She chaired the internship network.
Her real-estate company sponsored summer placements.
Families wanted access.
Students knew it.
“You think Mrs. Cole protected Brianna?”
Ms. Thompson shook her head.
“I said no such thing.”
“But—”
“Don’t build certainty out of suspicion.”
Lily smiled faintly.
“You sound like my mother.”
“Smart woman.”
Then Ms. Thompson opened a drawer.
“I kept something.”
She removed a small pink keychain.
A cracked plastic sunflower.
Lily recognized it.
It belonged to Hannah Walsh, a student who had transferred out the previous spring.
“She left this in the east restroom.”
“So?”
“Same day I found her crying beside a trash bin.”
Lily’s stomach tightened.
“Did Brianna do it?”
“Hannah wouldn’t say.”
“Can we contact her?”
“That decision belongs to the school.”
Lily nodded.
Then Ms. Thompson added, “But Principal Hayes already has the name.”
That afternoon, Hayes called Hannah’s mother.
By evening, Hannah Walsh agreed to speak.
Her family had not transferred because of academics, as everyone had been told.
They transferred because Hannah was terrified to return to Ashford.
May you like
And according to Hannah, Brianna Cole was the reason.
---
